Wednesday, 8 August 2018

Should Book Bloggers Get Paid?

I know this is something that keep getting discussed every now and again within the Book Blogging Community aka the Blogsphere, and normally, I stay away from this as my opinions are very mixed depending when you ask me and what mood I’m in. Or if I’ve just looked at my bank account and panicking about money, which is something I do often! 

But recently, I’ve started listening to a bunch of new podcasts and watching book vloggers and they ask for listeners and viewers to support them via Patreon. They are open about the fact that they put a lot of time and work into these projects and I 100% understand. 

But it’s interesting reading book bloggers thoughts on this throughout the past few years and I started to wonder about it as a whole. 

Now, before I go any further, this is going to be rambling. I’m not going to give an out-an-out answer on this. This is me, trying to understand and figure out where I stand in this. 

My thoughts are very mixed, like I said. I feel hugely uncomfortable about the idea of being paid to write a review or being involved in a blog tour. If I read a review on a blog I trust, I would question if the reviewer was being genuine over their review or was saying that the publisher/author/PR company/whoever is paying wanted them to say, if I find out that it was a paid review. 
We’ve seen backlash when several well-known vloggers in the US reviewed a book positively, only to discovered that they were paid. 

And what about adverts, I hear you ask? Hm… If I put adverts on my blog, I would want to be super careful on what goes up. I don’t want an advert that goes against my beliefs and the values I hold dear (for example, I won’t have anything anti-LGBTQ as am a gay man. Nor would I want anything racist, sexist among other things). Plus, if I did have adverts, I would only get revenue from them if someone clicks on it. And how often do we click on an ad? Or a clickbait ad? We’re more savvy now on this. 

“But, what about affiliates,” you ask? “You can put them in your reviews and put them to companies you use and trust”. Ok, this does seem the most logical step, but what company? Amazon? Waterstones? WHSmiths? Foyles? Audible? Book Depository? Hive? See… there are so many book sellers in the UK and there are so many forms of books - physical, ebook, audiobook - that instead of doing one, I would have to have several. And again, I would only get revenue from them if someone clicks that link to get a 30 day cookie and buys something. And even though, how much would I get if someone did that? Not very much - it’s between 5% to 10% on some of the sites I’ve looked into. 

What about Patreon and Ko-Fi? I mean, listening to podcasts and watching book vloggers saying they use Patreon and Ko-Fi and I get why. How pricy is a microphone, a camera, editing software? But for a book blogger such as myself? All I need is my laptop, wifi (which I can get free in most coffeeshops), a book or my eReader and not much else. Wouldn’t that feel a bit cap-in-hand?

Plus, would it be even worth it? I am not a huge blog. Hell, I am tiny! Really under the radar.  Would it be truly worth it for me to have an affiliate or a patreon/ko-fi? And do this while getting copies of books from publishers for free? 

See, that’s where I get stuck. Publishers, authors and publicity people are sending me books and ebooks (and making them aren’t cheap) and then, I would making money on the back of it. 

“But, hang on,”I hear you counter-argue. “They use your blog for free advertising and they make profit from that when the book sells. Doesn’t it seem unfair for you to do this for free while they make profit?”

This is something I have been questioning for at least a year or so. Me wondering if I should have something so, if you click it, I get some money. Money that I can put into the blog - buying my domain name, paying someone to create business cards for the blog or create a really cool banner, using the money for train fare when I got to events. But then I would question if it’s wise/sensible to ask for money from the blog’s reader, which then makes me question my worth and the blog’s as I have spent how much time/money/energy into this blog - a hobby I enjoy - which then makes me feel guilty because this is a hobby, plus I’m asking for money. This, in turns, makes me worried about money, my and the blog’s self-worth, which makes me think about using affiliate and thus, the cycle continues, though I do leave it a month or two before I go back into this rabbit hole. 

While I was on Twitter a few days/weeks ago, when I was thinking about writing this (or halfway through), I asked if other bloggers I know use affiliates and feel guilty about using them, and though only a tiny handful of people replied, most said the same thing: “I barely make any revenue from it so why feel guilty over it?”

I could go on about this. About me trying to figure out this as it does feel very much a mortal and it varies from person to person. For some people, this is a no brainer while to others, this is a bad idea and won’t go near it. 

For me, I think that, while I am totally against being paid for a review, I do feel less against using an affiliate and the forms of revenues, as long as they are sensible and for the blog. This would be my thread of thought, and if/when I finally feel comfortable about using affiliates/adverts/patreon/ko-fo/whatever, I would use what I feel is the best and most comfortable for myself and for the blog. 

But like I said before, this is a moral decision and it’s up to each blogger, vlogger, podcaster, creator to decide what is comfortable for them. 


EDIT: Ok, am writing this at a later date compared to the rest of the post as, when I wrote the above, I was wondering about affiliate and the morals and ethics of it, whereas now, you might have seen that I have an “Affiliate” tab and links on the side of the blog. After writing this post and having a long think about it, I did decide to get an affiliate or two. 

This wasn’t a decision I made lightly. 

But I thought of two, maybe three, things: if you read a write-up of a book or audiobook and you went “Oh, wow! I want to buy this or read more write-ups about this”, you can click on the seller of your choice, I would see what you guys like to read and go “Ok, you guys like this” and I can decide if I want to try reading more by that genre. Plus you guys can just click on a icon and you go straight to the seller of your choosing without leaving the blog. Ace. 

And now, the money. From the people I spoke to, you get little/nothing from affiliate so I thought “I have nothing to loe”. But, if I did get a tiny commission from you clicking/buying something, I could use that towards the blog - buying my domain name, train tickets to go to events, buy a book you guys have been screaming at me to buy/read. It would always go to the blog. 

So yes. I have affiliates. But I am not going to pressure you into using them. I’m having them on the side of the Pewter Wolf and on its own page/tab. Also, for a few months (maybe up till Christmas… Am still trying to figure this out), I will be doing a trail and putting links in the reviews at the very start. This will be a trail as I don’t want you guys to feel pressured. Like I said earlier in this post, I don’t want to pressure and I want to feel comfortable with them on the Pewter Wolf - if I feel comfortable with in them in the write-ups or discussion posts, I will keep doing them. If not, then I will remove them. I want the Pewter Wolf to remain friendly and safe space - like two friends chatting about books - so am going to figure this out and find what works best for me and you. 


*groans* seeing as I’m chatting about this, I suppose I better give you the links below so you can use, if you so wish. God, I suck at self-promotion…  

Free Delivery on all Books at Book Depository

   


2 comments:

  1. Go for it. Your time is also worth something. Plus, I had my biggest traffic month ever last month and made an enormous 26 cents. But I know the better web stats will also get me higher profile ARCs, so I’m just laughing at my “income”.

    You could use the United States FTC disclosure rules, if you’re concerned. That states that you have to disclose at the start of the post if you received free product/books and if you make anything from the links.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I would say that I wouldn't trust a review that was paid for. But editorial content and original posts, I think there's scope there for being paid.
    Being a book blogger is EXPENSIVE and if it weren't for the library and NetGalley I wouldn't be able to afford it. I buy 80% of the books I read, any giveaways are out of my own pocket, I pay for my domain. And yet when I've tried affiliate programs I was kicked out for not making enough (Amazon) or couldn't justify paying to join (Waterstones).
    Cora | http://teapartyprincess.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete